![]() Where is their data stored? Who has access to it? What happens if it “goes away”? Where are the written processes for governance of its administration? How do I know that the person I’m talking to is the same person with that ID on ? How can I be sure that if a person is blocked they won’t just setup another account?ĭrupalchat is in an interesting position. Quite rightly, questions are being asked about the setup of this new system but let’s not forget that Slack is not perfect in this regard, either. Especially for those new to our community - first impressions last. I do care, passionately, that whatever we use provides the safest and most welcoming environment possible. After all, the tool I use for creating Drupal is closed source. ![]() I genuinely couldn’t care less whether the tool I use for Instant messaging within the Drupal Community is Open Source or not. it would be good to have a comparison matrix between IRC, Slack, and this new platform, in these 4 areas (and possibly others I have forgotten). ![]() I don't see immediate answers to these questions in this issue. does this platform introduce?ĭ) Accessibility: Can users with screen readers use this service (all screenreaders? some screenreaders?) What about other accessibility groups using other types of adaptive technology or technology limitations (no mouse? large fonts? high contrast? etc.)? What about this new channel?ī) Usability: What features make this platform better/worse than Slack and IRC? Is it more or less usable/intiutive? What are the barriers for joining (do you need to download a specific client, etc.)? Is it usable all platforms (various desktop O/S, mobile, etc.)?Ĭ) Infrastructure: What infrastructure / load / maintenance burden / moderation burden etc. Slack is maintained by a company with its own interests. are maintained by large FOSS groups with a long history. Allows users to easily impersonate other users on d.o ( comment #225)īefore deciding to move to a different platform for chat, I think we should consider the following factors, which as far as I know, were not really considered when the community moved to Slack (not necessarily officially, but pretty much everyone stopped using IRC and switched to Slack):Ī) Software maintenance: Who is maintaining this platform, and is it sustainable? For instance, Drupal, Linux, IRC, etc.Does not and will not support Open Source communities.Does not have all of the above requirements.Prohibitively expensive to get backsroll.Architecturally has several types of limitations since their service is based on "small to medium" sized teams."Free" plan is intended for small to medium sized business/teams (Drupal is anything but).Project page for Issues: DrupalChat Service's Issuesįor a discussion of why Slack is not a good solution, please see the other issue.Documentation page on DO: Chat with the Drupal community using (Rocketchat).At DrupalCamp Ruhr, Essen, Germany the local communities decided to go away from slack and choose as the new platform for direct messaging.Ĭoming from #2490332: Evaluate whether to replace drupal IRC channels with another communication medium, I wanted to create this follow up so that we can direct the efforts towards going away from Slack and adopting.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |